Painting Contractors Worth Calling on Long Island, NY: 7 Options (2026)
Last updated: July 2026
Long Island's housing stock spans everything from century-old colonials with original plaster and cedar shake siding to newer construction, which means a painter who's great with modern drywall isn't automatically the right fit for a home with original 100-year-old materials. Add in the region's coastal humidity and salt air, which accelerates exterior wear, and the difference between a good Long Island painter and a mediocre one shows up faster here than in drier inland climates.
Here are 7 painting contractors worth calling across Long Island.
CBPro Painters LLC, based in Islip Terrace, serves all of Long Island with residential and commercial painting alongside specialized finishes: epoxy flooring, epoxy countertops, cabinet painting, wall retexturing, and varnishing. The company uses Sherwin Williams and Benjamin Moore products exclusively and positions itself around professional work, personalized service, and attention to detail in every project.
Painting Contractors Long Island, run by Joel, has built a reputation for creative problem-solving beyond standard painting — one reviewer described Joel identifying solutions to renovation issues they hadn't even considered, including removing a wall and reworking a room layout as part of a broader project alongside the paint work itself.
Long Island Painting and Restoration, run by Andres, stands out for correcting existing drywall and prep issues before painting, with one detailed review describing the crew fixing amateur sheetrock work and completing a full 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom home in under 48 hours with thorough cleanup.
Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County has particular strength with older homes, including one case of successfully painting the exterior of a 230-year-old house after providing a detailed pre-painting checklist of repairs (loose clapboard, rotting windowsills) needed before work could begin.
South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC, run by Todd, combines painting with power washing services, with reviewers specifically praising careful attention around landscaping and property, plus a specific case of a team member spending extra time teaching a homeowner proper door-painting technique at no additional charge.
Walker Painting, run by Sal, has built loyalty through generous, flexible service — including replacing more damaged cedar shingles than originally quoted at no extra cost, and successfully matching shingle colors on aging homes with cedar shake siding, a specialty not every painter handles well.
Chameleon Painting Inc., run by Juan, based in Hampton Bays, has built trust through consistent, on-schedule delivery across varied projects, including cabinet staining to match existing finishes and coordinating additional trades (electrical, deck rebuilding) as part of a broader project scope.
Quick comparison
| Contractor | Location | Rating | Known For | Phone |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CBPro Painters LLC | Islip Terrace | — | Epoxy flooring, countertops, full-service finishes | 631-748-5627 |
| Painting Contractors Long Island | Lindenhurst | 5.0 (79) | Creative renovation problem-solving | 516-661-0074 |
| Long Island Painting and Restoration | Bay Shore | 5.0 (165) | Drywall correction, fast turnaround | 631-231-2119 |
| Precision Painting Plus of Suffolk County | Melville | 4.9 (182) | Older home and historic exterior expertise | 631-250-8014 |
| South Bay Painting and Power Washing LLC | East Islip | 5.0 (222) | Combined painting and power washing | 631-383-7491 |
| Walker Painting | Seaford | 5.0 (298) | Cedar shake specialty, generous service | 516-447-2732 |
| Chameleon Painting Inc. | Hampton Bays | 5.0 (187) | Reliable scheduling, multi-trade coordination | 631-764-1183 |
CBPro Painters LLC in more detail
CBPro Painters LLC serves all of Long Island with a philosophy built around professional work, personalized service, and perfection in every detail. Beyond standard interior and exterior residential and commercial painting, the company offers specialized finishes including epoxy flooring and countertops, cabinet painting, and wall retexturing — a broader range of services than most standard painting contractors provide. Every project uses Sherwin Williams and Benjamin Moore materials exclusively.
Services offered: Residential painting, interior painting, exterior painting, commercial painting, cabinet painting, wall retexturing, epoxy flooring, epoxy countertops, varnishing walls
Service area: All of Long Island, NY
Contact: cbpropainters.info | 631-748-5627
What to look for in a Long Island painting contractor
For older homes, ask specifically about experience with original materials. Long Island's older housing stock includes plaster walls, cedar shake siding, and other materials that require different techniques than modern drywall and vinyl siding. A contractor experienced with your home's specific era and materials will get better, longer-lasting results.
Coastal exterior work benefits from contractors who understand salt air and humidity effects. Exterior paint and materials near the coast wear differently than inland. Ask directly how a contractor adjusts material choice or preparation for coastal exposure.
If you want epoxy flooring, countertops, or similar specialty finishes, confirm specific experience. Not every painting contractor offers these services, and the technique differs meaningfully from standard wall painting. Confirm direct experience rather than assuming general painting skill transfers.
Ask whether pre-painting repairs are identified upfront. Contractors who provide a detailed pre-painting checklist (like addressing loose siding or rotting wood before painting begins) tend to deliver more durable, professional results than those who paint over existing problems.
Cedar shake and shingle matching requires specific expertise. If your home has cedar shake siding, confirm a contractor has specific experience color-matching and repairing this material, since it's a specialty not every painter handles well.
How much does painting cost on Long Island?
- Single interior room: $350–$800
- Whole-house interior (3-4 bedroom home): $3,500–$8,000
- Exterior repaint (average home): $4,000–$9,000
- Historic/older home exterior (extensive prep required): $6,000–$15,000+
- Cabinet painting/refinishing: $2,500–$6,000 depending on kitchen size
- Epoxy flooring (per project): $1,500–$5,000+ depending on square footage
- Cedar shake repair and repainting: Priced per project based on extent of damage
Long Island pricing tends to run somewhat higher than national averages, reflecting both regional cost of living and the additional prep work often required for the area's older housing stock.
Frequently asked questions
Do older Long Island homes need special painting preparation?
Often, yes. Many older homes have plaster walls, cedar shake siding, or other materials that require different prep and technique than modern construction. A contractor experienced with your home's specific era and materials will typically identify necessary repairs before painting begins.
How does coastal weather affect exterior painting on Long Island?
Salt air and humidity near the coast can accelerate paint wear compared to inland areas. Some contractors adjust material choices or add extra prep steps for coastal-exposed homes, so it's worth asking directly if you're near the water.
What is epoxy flooring, and who should consider it?
Epoxy flooring is a durable, seamless coating often used in garages, basements, or commercial spaces for its resistance to stains and wear. Not every painting contractor offers this service, so confirm specific experience if considering it.
Can painting contractors match existing cedar shake or shingle colors?
Some specialize in this specifically, which is a genuinely different skill than standard exterior painting. If a home has cedar shake siding needing repair or color matching, confirm a contractor's specific experience with this material.
Should a painting contractor identify repairs needed before painting?
Yes, ideally. A thorough contractor will inspect for issues like rotting wood, loose siding, or damaged trim and address these before painting, since painting over unresolved problems leads to faster paint failure and a less professional result.
Is it worth getting multiple quotes for a Long Island painting project?
Yes, particularly for larger or historic home projects where prep work scope can vary significantly between contractors. Comparing two or three detailed quotes helps confirm equivalent scope of work is being compared.
How long does a typical painting project take on Long Island?
A single room can often be completed in a day, while a full interior repaint for an average home typically takes 3 to 5 days. Older homes requiring extensive prep, or larger exterior projects, can take a week or more.
This page is maintained by Mighty Sites, a platform that helps local service businesses get found online. CBPro Painters LLC uses Mighty Sites for their website. We've researched and listed painting contractors on Long Island to help local homeowners and businesses find reliable options. To suggest an addition or correction, contact us. Last updated July 2026.